Offering a $10 gift card, a discount code or early product access in exchange for a review is one of the fastest ways to grow review volume, and one of the easiest ways to get into trouble with regulators and review platforms. Incentivized reviews are not banned outright, but the disclosure requirements around them have become much stricter since 2023. This article explains what the law in the US, UK and EU actually requires, how the major platforms differ, and how to run a review program that protects your brand reputation.
What Counts as an Incentivized Review
An incentivized review is any review where the writer received something of value connected to writing it. That includes cash, gift cards, free products, discounts, sweepstakes entries, loyalty points and free months of a subscription. It also includes less obvious cases, such as a reviewer who is a friend of the founder or an employee reviewing their own company’s product.
The legal test is the material connection. Under the FTC Endorsement Guides, revised in June 2023, a material connection exists when the relationship could affect how much weight a reader gives the review. A $5 coupon counts. The size of the reward does not decide whether disclosure is needed.
The Legal Framework in the US, UK and EU
In the US, two documents matter. The Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255) set out the disclosure requirements. The FTC’s Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465) took effect on October 21, 2024, and gave the agency the power to seek civil penalties of more than $51,000 per violation. The rule prohibits conditioning an incentive on the sentiment of the review, whether the condition is stated outright or implied. “Leave a review for 15% off” can be lawful. “Leave a 5-star review for 15% off” is not. Detailed coverage of the rule is in our article on FTC rules on fake reviews and what they mean for brands.
In the UK, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 added fake reviews and concealed incentivized reviews to the list of banned practices from April 6, 2025. The CMA can now impose fines directly, up to 10% of global turnover. In the EU, the Omnibus Directive (2019/2161), in force since May 2022, requires businesses that publish reviews to explain whether and how they check that reviews come from real customers. Enforcement varies by country, and Germany and the Netherlands have been noticeably more active than most.
Platform Rules Are Often Stricter Than the Law
Here many brands go wrong. Something legal under FTC rules can still get your listing penalized. Amazon has banned incentivized reviews outside its own Vine program since 2016. Google’s review policy forbids offering anything of value in exchange for reviews, and businesses caught doing so have had reviews removed in bulk. Yelp goes further and discourages asking for reviews at all.
B2B software platforms work differently. G2 and Capterra run their own gift-card campaigns and label the resulting reviews, which is one reason buyers there have learned to weigh incentivized feedback in context. The dynamics of those platforms are covered in how G2 and Capterra reviews influence B2B buying decisions. Trustpilot’s guidelines also restrict incentives, so read the current version before any campaign.
Myth: Disclosing in the Invitation Email Is Enough
A lot of marketers believe this, and it’s wrong. Telling the customer “you’ll receive a $10 credit” in your request email does nothing for the person who later reads the review on Google or Trustpilot. Readers need to see the disclosure in or next to the review itself.
In practice, that means you ask reviewers to include a line such as “I received a free month in exchange for an honest review,” or you use a platform that adds an incentive label automatically. If neither is possible on a given platform, that platform is usually not suitable for incentivized reviews at all.
How to Build a Compliant Incentive Program
An experienced reputation manager plans the program around disclosure before choosing the reward. A workable sequence looks like this:
1. Check the rules for each platform you plan to use and drop any platform that prohibits incentives.
2. Offer the reward to everyone who reviews, regardless of rating, and state that in the invitation.
3. Tell reviewers what disclosure to write and give them a sample sentence.
4. Never filter invitations so that only happy customers receive them. The FTC rule covers review suppression too.
5. Keep records of who received what and when, for at least 2-3 years.
Plan on spot-checking manually. With 200-400 incentivized reviews a quarter, sampling 10% for missing disclosures takes about an hour and finds most problems before a competitor or regulator does.
A Scenario Most Brand Managers Will Recognize
A mid-sized eCommerce store launches a new product line and offers a 20% discount to anyone who reviews within 30 days. The campaign works, and the product goes from 12 reviews to 180 in six weeks. Then a customer posts on Reddit that the store’s support agents were telling buyers the code would only arrive “after your 5-star review.” Nobody in marketing knew.
Within days, screenshots spread, Google removes a batch of reviews, and the average rating drops from 4.7 to 4.1. Marketing designed the campaign correctly, but customer service carried it out differently. Brands that monitor review sites and forums continuously usually spot this kind of drift in the first week, when fixing it still costs little.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
The most frequent mistake is gating. A brand sends a satisfaction survey first and sends the review link only to customers who scored 9 or 10. It looks harmless, but it is review suppression under the FTC rule, and Google explicitly prohibits it.
The second mistake is assuming that a contract with an agency transfers the liability to the agency. It doesn’t. If a third-party review agency buys reviews or skips disclosures, the brand is the one that benefits and will usually be named as well.
The third is ignoring old reviews. Incentivized reviews from 2021 without disclosures are still public and still count. Auditing the backlog matters as much as fixing new campaigns. Small teams of under 10 people are often hit hardest here, because one founder ran a launch campaign years ago and nobody remembers the terms.
FAQ
Are incentivized reviews illegal?
No. In the US, UK and EU, offering an incentive for an honest review is lawful if the incentive is clearly disclosed and does not depend on the review being positive. Individual platforms such as Amazon and Google may still prohibit them.
Does a free product sample require disclosure?
Yes. A free product is something of value, so the reviewer should state that they received it for free. This applies even if the reviewer would have bought the product anyway.
Can employees review their own company’s products?
Only with clear disclosure of the employment relationship, and many platforms forbid it entirely. Most companies are better off banning it in their social media policy.
Final Practical Tip
Treat incentivized reviews as a compliance project as well as a marketing tactic. Offer the reward regardless of rating, make sure the disclosure appears in the review itself, follow the strictest platform’s rules, and audit both new and old reviews regularly. Honest incentivized reviews with clear labels build trust, while hidden incentives can cost a brand both its review history and its credibility.
